![]() |
Brick Wall Assumption
At any given moment, the location of the train ahead is determined by its "tail car," which is assumed to be situated at the rear-most boundary of the track block in which it is detected. For safety, it is also appropriate to assume that an impenetrable barrier is located at that boundary -- and that the barrier will stay there until the train ahead no longer occupies the block. Accordingly, as the preceding train moves forward, the so-called "brick wall" gets torn down and immediately re-built at the next block boundary, leaping logically from block to block. Sketches like the one below apply what is known in mathematics as a "phase-plane plot" -- a graph of velocity against displacement (in this case, train speed versus track location). ![]() xC0 = vC2 / 2 dS ...where dS is a constant deceleration as customarily modeled for "service braking." The train comes to a stop at Point 3, which is deliberately targeted at a distance xB in approach to the brick wall located at Point 4. The size of xB is mostly attributable to the fixed-block design and represents a "buffer" distance that allows for uncertainty in the stopped location of the train-in-trail.
tH = tM + [(vC2 / 2 dS) + xB] / vC. Solutions for the Trail Braking
puzzle are provided by the graph on the right using "base-case" values
as follows: train length xL = 700 feet, mode-change delay
tM
= 4 seconds, and service brake rate dS = 3 miles per hour
per second (mphps).
Meanwhile, the abbreviation "CBTC" in the graph legend stands for Communications Based Train Control, an advanced system which achieves the effect of extremely short block lengths -- as if the brick wall gets torn down permanently. The result is called "moving-block" train control. The graph shows that CBTC will support the same headway (tH = 34 seconds) at cruise speeds over 90 miles per hour -- a potential savings of more than 30 seconds per mile in trip-time. By the way, even a fixed-block system can handle more than a train a minute (tH = 60 seconds) at cruise speeds exceeding 100 miles per hour. Oh right, there is just this one other matter. Passengers. And Station Stops. |
Home Page Puzzle Page Reasoning Meets the Rails The Puzzle as a Literary Genre