Riddle from Hell

Copyright ©1997 by Paul Niquette.  All rights reserved.

The conundrum in the puzzle...
 
What is it a dead person eats? And yet why... 
When eaten while living, it makes each one die?

What is it in darkness we see as a tint? 

What is it in riddles we trust as a hint?

What is it that neatness will leave out of place? 

What is it that fills every void beyond space?

What is it that's better than heaven, pray tell? 

What is it that's thought to be far worse than hell?

 
Nothing
Let's take a cyber-run at nothing with conventional journalistic questions... 
who? 
     what? 
          why? 
               where? 
                    when?


Who?
 

Set up a search for "Seinfeld" AND "nothing" and you will get more than 10,000 webpages. Apparently, nothing is popular enough as a subject to deserve some sophisticated attention, but...
What?
Visit a cyber-dictionary for a self-referent joke.
"Enter the word," commands the window. 
So you type "n o t h i n g"
"Aw come on!" complains the dictionary.

Why?

Thing is, English -- hey, every language -- needs nothing, which is really something, is it not? Consider the following paradox (with apologies to Bertrand Russell):
Nothing is a class. Does it include itself?

The answer is yes, it includes itself, therefore it must be included in the class of all classes which include themselves.

On the contrary...

The answer is no, it does not include itself, it is a class which does not include itself and therefore must be included in the class of all classes which do not include themselves, so the answer is yes, it includes itself, then it is not a class which does not include itself and therefore must not be included in the class of all classes which do not include themselves, so the answer is no, it does not include itself, it is a class which does not include itself and therefore must be included in the class of all classes which do not include themselves, so the answer is yes, it includes itself, then it is not a class which does not include itself and therefore must not be included in the class of all classes which do not include themselves, so the answer is ... 

Where?

Contrary to the line in the poem above which reads, "What is it that fills every void beyond space?" you won't find nothing in outer space. Look for "dark matter" instead, which is decidedly not nothing. Our queries have carried us from the ridiculous and benign to the cosmic and controversial...

The 'Big Bang' postulates that the cosmological expansion occurs, not because galaxies move apart through space, but because more space is being continually added between them. That's nothing. This continual creation of space -- nothing -- ex nihilo is an integral part of the theory. Without it, the cosmological principle would be violated. 

Now, the argument that substitutes the hypothetical "dark matter" for nothing is itself a fudge factor required to obtain agreement with observations that were not in accord with 'Big Bang' expectations, and nothing comes in three flavors: hot, cold, or mixed. The complexities do not surrender easily to Occam's Razor, but nothing comes to the rescue since we prefer the model with fewest free parameters.

Nota bene, an original conjecture about "dark matter" 
is put forward in the solution to the puzzle entitled
To Billow or Not to Billow.
For more about this controversy have a look at 
Metaresearch:DidTheUniverseHaveABeginning?

When?

As important as it may be, English apparently got along without nothing until the 12th century...according to one dictionary* -- which gives us another paradox:
And in the beginning there was nothing.
And God said 'Let there be light.' 
And there was still nothing, but now you could see it! 
-- Anonymous 
Whether you can see it or not, you simply cannot say there is nothing in the Bible.

* nothing NUXEQ

Etymology: Middle English, from Old English non-thing, nothing, from non + thing thing.  Date: nothing before the 12th century

1 : not any thing : no thing 
       <leaves nothing to the imagination
2 : no part 
3 : one of no interest, value, or consequence 
       <they mean nothing to me


 

Bonus Puzzle Solution
English
Français
birth before pregnancy
accouchement avant grossesse
adult before youth
adulte avant jeunesse
death before life
mort avant vie
Who am I?
Qui suis-je ?
A dictionary
Un dictionnaire



 


Home Page
Puzzle Page
Words and Meanings
The Puzzle as a Literary Genre